#2 Gophers at #3 Mi...
 
Notifications
Clear all




[Closed] #2 Gophers at #3 Michigan -- Nov 17 & 18

218 Posts
46 Users
81 Reactions
6,002 Views
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Rep Pts: 1821
Post on old board: 6912
 

Disagree…How the refs didn’t give Cooley a Major & a game misconduct is beyond me, the hit was dirty & reckless & warranted an ejection Friday. He should have been able to play on Saturday, but since the refs screwed up the call Friday…the Big Ten reviewed it Saturday & suspended him as essentially as make up. If an opponent hit Cooley in exactly the same fashion, GPLers would be absolutely incensed! It’s all whose OX is being Gored. 


   
JoeGopher, gator, MN State 0f Hockey and 1 people reacted
HandyNotDan
(@handyman)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1840
Rep Pts: 5152
Post on old board: 28736
 

Oh stop.  If that is worthy of a suspension NoDak would be shorthanded every week. (As would about half the country) It was dumb, it should have been a two and that is it.  And ask around I'm the guy who usually agrees with erring on the side of caution on plays like that.  The play looks dangerous cause he lost his edge just like all the phantom holdings and slashes all weekend for either team.  And I absolutely would not be upset if that happened to us that is cop out.

I'm watching Game 2 right now...Motzko was going to kill the ref when they allowed the goal with 7 guys on the ice.  How that held up on review...

 

 


   
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Rep Pts: 1821
Post on old board: 6912

   
mlhouse
(@mlhouse)
Wooger Level
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 174
Rep Pts: 404
 

@bearpaw28   Bullshit.  The hit was a normal in the course of the action play, nothing overtly "dirty".  I agree with the 5 minute major, but that is only because of the result and it was a marginal 5 minute call at that.  

 

 


   
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Rep Pts: 1821
Post on old board: 6912
 

@mlhouse lmao…when Snuggy or Cooley or Knies are on the other end of the exact same cheap hit…something tells me you’ll react differently  ? ?


   
Norm
 Norm
(@norm)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1070
Rep Pts: 2212
 

Michigan games are always fun. It's nice to watch 2 teams whose strategy isn't to just clog things up and wait for a break.


   
wincav reacted
USHANABI
(@ushanabi)
Lucia Level
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 69
Rep Pts: 189
 

Posted by: @north45

Am I the only person who has found this "new " site to be very slow loading?  Last night during the game the site wasn't working at all.   

No, have enjoyed the "new" site until last evening and even into this morning . . . wasn't able to get into chat until late and then unable to get back into the site after the win . . . was wondering whether or not others were having problems . . . .

Go Gophers!

 

 

Not knowing what to do, they do what they know . . .
Knowing what to do, they sometime don't do it . . .
The 26th year of the Gopher Men's Hockey Profile got to be too much for this ol' codger to handle . . . what with all of the possible activity on the transfer portal . . . . So, I'm closing it down at the 25th year . . .


   




Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2766
Rep Pts: 5442
Post on old board: 10695
 

The entire site was offline due to an issue with the host early in the morning until it looks like several hours after the game completed last night.

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
wincav
(@wincav)
Wooger Level
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 143
Rep Pts: 255
 

Posted by: @norm

Michigan games are always fun. It's nice to watch 2 teams whose strategy isn't to just clog things up and wait for a break.

So true!

 


   
GopherPete
(@gopherpete)
Wooger Level
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 193
Rep Pts: 478
 

I agree with Bearpaw that the Cooley hit was cheap and deserving of a suspension. I thought he should have been kicked out of the game. No reason to push a player from behind at full speed when you are at the goal line. Not smart at all. That hit was the definition of hits that need to be eliminated from the game.


   
Jupiter ♃ reacted
Sunbone
(@sunbone)
Wooger Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 141
Rep Pts: 246
Post on old board: 8761
 

Posted by: @gopherpete

I agree with Bearpaw that the Cooley hit was cheap and deserving of a suspension. I thought he should have been kicked out of the game. No reason to push a player from behind at full speed when you are at the goal line. Not smart at all. That hit was the definition of hits that need to be eliminated from the game.

i agree completely. Dangerous play.

 


   
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2766
Rep Pts: 5442
Post on old board: 10695
 

Dirty, no.

Dangerous, probably yes.

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


MN State 0f Hockey
(@mnstate0fhockey)
Micheletti Level
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 163
Rep Pts: 588
 

Posted by: @steve-mn

Dirty, no.

Dangerous, probably yes.

Agreed.  Call it dangerous and worthy of suspension, which I can see.  But to call it “dirty” signifies intent to injure and that is a bridge too far.  I don’t think there was any intent to injure. 

 


   
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1231
Rep Pts: 1821
Post on old board: 6912
 

Posted by: @mnstate0fhockey

Posted by: @steve-mn

Dirty, no.

Dangerous, probably yes.

Agreed.  Call it dangerous and worthy of suspension, which I can see.  But to call it “dirty” signifies intent to injure and that is a bridge too far.  I don’t think there was any intent to injure. 

 

I don’t necessarily equate “dirty” with intent to injure, but I do equate it to “cheap” “reckless” and “dangerous”. He F-cked up…period…but hopefully will learn from it and not repeat it. Hey, they still got the ?without Cooley in the lineup on Saturday & Bart had a strong series in goal. 

 


   




HandyNotDan
(@handyman)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1840
Rep Pts: 5152
Post on old board: 28736
 

Well reasonable people can disagree reasonably.   


   
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 1001
Rep Pts: 2341
Post on old board: 5631
 

For those arguing that the Cooley hit was/should have been a major. What penalty would you call?


   
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2766
Rep Pts: 5442
Post on old board: 10695
 

Posted by: @j22

For those arguing that the Cooley hit was/should have been a major. What penalty would you call?

It WAS called a major for cross-checking, but no game misconduct.  Watching it live, I expected it to be called a check from behind or maybe boarding.

 

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 1001
Rep Pts: 2341
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @steve-mn

Posted by: @j22

For those arguing that the Cooley hit was/should have been a major. What penalty would you call?

It WAS called a major for cross-checking, but no game misconduct.  Watching it live, I expected it to be called a check from behind or maybe boarding.

 

It clearly wasn't a crosscheck. There's no way you can call a guy for boarding on a hit that happens in front of the net. I guess you could defend calling it from behind, but I personally wouldn't agree with that.

 


   
Page 5 / 5