MN Wild 24-25 Seaso...
 
Notifications
Clear all




MN Wild 24-25 Season

174 Posts
32 Users
33 Reactions
3,909 Views
Koho
 Koho
(@koho)
Wooger Level
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 126
Rep Pts: 401
 

Posted by: @youngeagle

 

 

Love the Buium draft pick.  

 

In the long term, I agree.  Kid looks like he will be as good as a Hughes. Could add offense like no D we have seen.  But admit I was sort of hoping (as a Gopher fan first) that someone like Utah (seems strange to say) would take him and bring him into the NHL right away.

 


   
grothm01 reacted
ReplyQuote
Koho
 Koho
(@koho)
Wooger Level
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 126
Rep Pts: 401
 

Posted by: @kelly-red

Posted by: @jwg

After the Faber and Middleton Wild Thing video at Valleyfair they had no choice but to extend Middleton... 🤣 

 

I just watched this, very funny.  Whoever matched up the rides to the various teams was brilliant.  The Octopus ride for the Kraken, the Yellow Duck midway game for the Ducks, Wild Card for Vegas, very clever.  

 

 

Utah is a merry-go-round?  Easiest ride at the park?

 


   
ReplyQuote
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1220
Rep Pts: 1800
Post on old board: 6912
 

Posted by: @koho

Posted by: @youngeagle

 

 

Love the Buium draft pick.  

 

In the long term, I agree.  Kid looks like he will be as good as a Hughes. Could add offense like no D we have seen.  But admit I was sort of hoping (as a Gopher fan first) that someone like Utah (seems strange to say) would take him and bring him into the NHL right away.

 

To say you’re getting ahead of yourself worrying about Buium returning to Denver…is an UNDERSTATEMENT☝️He won’t sign until the end of next season at the earliest, but Denver doesn’t even play in the same conference as the Gophers. lol

 

 


   
ReplyQuote
Koho
 Koho
(@koho)
Wooger Level
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 126
Rep Pts: 401
 

Posted by: @bearpaw28

Posted by: @koho

Posted by: @youngeagle

 

 

Love the Buium draft pick.  

 

In the long term, I agree.  Kid looks like he will be as good as a Hughes. Could add offense like no D we have seen.  But admit I was sort of hoping (as a Gopher fan first) that someone like Utah (seems strange to say) would take him and bring him into the NHL right away.

 

To say you’re getting ahead of yourself worrying about Buium returning to Denver…is an UNDERSTATEMENT☝️He won’t sign until the end of next season at the earliest, but Denver doesn’t even play in the same conference as the Gophers. lol

 

 

 

It's all about the last game!

 


   
ReplyQuote
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1220
Rep Pts: 1800
Post on old board: 6912
 

Posted by: @koho

Posted by: @bearpaw28

Posted by: @koho

Posted by: @youngeagle

 

 

Love the Buium draft pick.  

 

In the long term, I agree.  Kid looks like he will be as good as a Hughes. Could add offense like no D we have seen.  But admit I was sort of hoping (as a Gopher fan first) that someone like Utah (seems strange to say) would take him and bring him into the NHL right away.

 

To say you’re getting ahead of yourself worrying about Buium returning to Denver…is an UNDERSTATEMENT☝️He won’t sign until the end of next season at the earliest, but Denver doesn’t even play in the same conference as the Gophers. lol

 

 

 

It's all about the last game!

 

1) You’re clearly not a fan of the Wild if U would have preferred Utah drafting Buium. 2) Gophers have A LOT of work to do before advancing to the last game (so does Denver)      

 


   
ReplyQuote
MikeEruzione11
(@mikeeruzione11)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 1888
Rep Pts: 5003

   
ReplyQuote
Bertogliat
(@bertogliat)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 2523
Rep Pts: 4747
Post on old board: 12555
 

Was this expected?  Seems too much too soon.

 

He was obviously one of the best rookies.  But he received no votes for Norris trophy and finished outside the top 20 for defenseman scoring.  I realize he was just a rookie, but we're now paying him top dollar....13th highest paid defenseman in the NHL by yearly compensation.

https://frontofficesports.com/the-25-highest-paid-nhl-defensemen/

 

I know they have some cap room after next season, I just hope Billy doesn't spend it all over paying for current roster (excluding Kaprisov) and there will be room to pay Kirill plus a couple key free agents.

 


   
ReplyQuote




team2tank
(@team2tank)
Wooger Level
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 133
Rep Pts: 208
 

Posted by: @bertogliat

Was this expected?  Seems too much too soon.

 

He was obviously one of the best rookies.  But he received no votes for Norris trophy and finished outside the top 20 for defenseman scoring.  I realize he was just a rookie, but we're now paying him top dollar....13th highest paid defenseman in the NHL by yearly compensation.

https://frontofficesports.com/the-25-highest-paid-nhl-defensemen/

 

I know they have some cap room after next season, I just hope Billy doesn't spend it all over paying for current roster (excluding Kaprisov) and there will be room to pay Kirill plus a couple key free agents.

 

This contract won't start until the 2025-2026 so he won't be the 13th highest paid this season.

They are making a bet that he will be worth a lot more than this throughout the contract and they have him locked down for the prime of his career.

 


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

It's just how Guerin does contracts. Overpay and get everything locked up well before it's necessary.  This isn't a terrible contract, but if Faber wasn't willing to give the discount, then Guerin should've forced him to prove himself with a 2nd season.


   
ReplyQuote
gopher hockey fan 7
(@gopherhockeyfan7)
Lucia Level
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 72
Rep Pts: 157
 

If he proves himself a 2nd season, the number jumps up over 9 likely. 

 

It's a gamble that can pay off with massive value if he becomes the #1 defenseman he's on track to be. This is a great signing that any team in the NHL would've made.


   
ReplyQuote
Rau4SkiUMah
(@rau4skiumah)
Broten Level
Joined: 5 years ago
Posts: 993
Rep Pts: 2463
 

He’s the Prince that was promised. It has been written in the stars. 


   
ReplyQuote
upnorthkid
(@upnorthkid)
Broten Level
Joined: 10 years ago
Posts: 1268
Rep Pts: 2858
 

 this deal decent. Think I would’ve rather seen a mid year deal in the 5 AAV range if it could’ve gotten done but if you’re expecting the cap is going to go up a decent amount (and Faber continues to grow like he did this year), this deal will look very good over its lifespan. I’d guess you could’ve signed him at this exact same number at seasons end as well as others have mentioned (maybe slightly higher in the 9 range if he’s an all star, but as an RFA, they’ll hold all the cards on matching). 


   
ReplyQuote
g-manpuck
(@g-manpuck)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1103
Rep Pts: 2710
Post on old board: 6782
 

Honestly I think this fanbase still has Suter/Parise syndrome which makes us leery of any contract longer than three years.

I am the official Iowa Hawkeye football fan of GPL!


   
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5841
Rep Pts: 13809
Post on old board: 9626
 

For some, it is a no win situation for Guerin. It reminds me of the Joe Mauer situation. If the Twins didn't sign him, outrage would have happened. When they signed him, he didn't live up to the contract and people were up in arms. Same for Faber. He is our beloved son, and I am glad they signed him and hope he becomes a perennial all star.

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
ReplyQuote




bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1220
Rep Pts: 1800
Post on old board: 6912
 

Posted by: @frozen4champs

For some, it is a no win situation for Guerin. It reminds me of the Joe Mauer situation. If the Twins didn't sign him, outrage would have happened. When they signed him, he didn't live up to the contract and people were up in arms. Same for Faber. He is our beloved son, and I am glad they signed him and hope he becomes a perennial all star.

I disagree, I doesn’t remind me a bit of the Joe Mauer situation. Joe Mauer played for cheapskate owners in a sport where no salary CAP exists…where the cheapskate owners reluctantly paid Mauer because they literally had a gun to their heads, had no choice because Joe was decreed…the hometown Baby Jesus. Faber is a TC kid who plays for owners who consistently spend to an actual salary CAP & if Brock fulfills his potential, the 8.5 AAV will seem like a bargain in a few years. 

 


   
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5841
Rep Pts: 13809
Post on old board: 9626
 

Posted by: @bearpaw28

Posted by: @frozen4champs

For some, it is a no win situation for Guerin. It reminds me of the Joe Mauer situation. If the Twins didn't sign him, outrage would have happened. When they signed him, he didn't live up to the contract and people were up in arms. Same for Faber. He is our beloved son, and I am glad they signed him and hope he becomes a perennial all star.

I disagree, I doesn’t remind me a bit of the Joe Mauer situation. Joe Mauer played for cheapskate owners in a sport where no salary CAP exists…where the cheapskate owners reluctantly paid Mauer because they literally had a gun to their heads, had no choice because Joe was decreed…the hometown Baby Jesus. Faber is a TC kid who plays for owners who consistently spend to an actual salary CAP & if Brock fulfills his potential, the 8.5 AAV will seem like a bargain in a few years. 

 

I guess I wasn't very clear with my thoughts. The situation in the fans eyes are similar, not in the owners situation.  I 100% agree with the Faber signing. 

 

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
bearpaw28 reacted
ReplyQuote
Suffering Sota Fan
(@sufferingsotafan)
Wooger Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 138
Rep Pts: 348
 

In Today's $ the $8.5M seems high at first glance. Should Faber be Paid like a top 15 D in the league? But when you think about inflation and Faber's Age it makes a lot more sense to me.    

  • Remember the 8.5M starts next year, 2025,  and the salary cap will go up from todays $88M. 
  • In the last 18 years the salary cap has gone up from $39M to $88M.
    • ( that equates to ~4.6% average increase each year )
  •   Faber will be 30 when this contract ends so he will still be in his prime. This is not a Parise/Suter Situation where the contract goes into the player's late 30s.   
  • Today the top 10 highest paid D make $9M-$11.5 M
  • Using the 4.6% inflation estimate, by 2032 the top 10 highest paid D would be in the $12M-$16M Range.  

 

It is a bit weird to think that Faber is already getting paid this much. In football and even Baseball it seems there is more focus on building around cheap young talent to offset the "overpaid" veterans. Given Faber's Minnesota connections could Guerin reasonably push off Faber's contract a few more years and not risk losing him?  Hard to say but as a fan I know what my next Wild Jersey will be, and that cant be a bad thing 😀. 

 

Rank Player Team Yearly Compensation
1 Erik Karlsson Pittsburgh Penguins $11.5 million
T-2 Rasmus Dahlin Buffalo Sabres $11 million
T-2 Drew Doughty Los Angeles Kings $11 million
4 Zachary Werenski Columbus Blue Jackets $9.58 million
T-5 Charles Mcavoy Boston Bruins $9.5 million
T-5 Seth Jones Chicago Blackhawks $9.5 million
T-5 Adam Fox New York Rangers $9.5 million
8 Darnell Nurse Edmonton Oilers $9.25 million
9 Roman Josi Nashville Predators $9.06 million
T-10 Cale Makar Colorado Avalanche $9 million
T-10 Dougie Hamilton New Jersey Devils $9 million
12 Alex Pietrangelo Vegas Golden Knights $8.8 million
13 Mikhail Sergachev Tampa Bay Lightning $8.5 million
14 Miro Heiskanen Dallas Stars $8.45 million
15 Owen Power Buffalo Sabres $8.35 million
T-16 Brent Burns Carolina Hurricanes $8 million
T-16 Jacob Trouba New York Rangers $8 million
T-16 Jake Sanderson Ottawa Senators $8 million
T-16 Thomas Chabot Ottawa Senators $8 million
T-16 John Carlson Washington Capitals $8 million
21 Victor Hedman Tampa Bay Lightning $7.88 million
22 Shea Weber Utah Hockey Club $7.86 million
23 Quinn Hughes Vancouver Canucks $7.85 million
24 Dmitry Orlov Carolina Hurricanes $7.75 million
25 Jared Spurgeon Minnesota Wild $7.58 million

 

      4.6% increases      
Year Faber Age Faber Salary Projected cap % of Cap Example 10% of Cap Salary Example 13% of Cap Salary
2025 23 8.5 92.0 9.23% $9.20 $11.97
2026 24 8.5 96.3 8.83% $9.63 $12.52
2027 25 8.5 100.7 8.44% $10.07 $13.09
2028 26 8.5 105.3 8.07% $10.53 $13.69
2029 27 8.5 110.2 7.71% $11.02 $14.32
2030 28 8.5 115.3 7.37% $11.53 $14.98
2031 29 8.5 120.6 7.05% $12.06 $15.67
2032 30 8.5 126.1 6.74% $12.61 $16.39

 

 


   
ReplyQuote
Slap Shot
(@slap-shot)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 4029
Rep Pts: 8261
Post on old board: 18942
 

Faber is the best (2nd best?) defenseman already on the MIN (current in in the pool) and is a future C or A. He appears to be the type of guy that will take care of himself, won't be a locker-room cancer, and is going to put in the effort to get better rather than rest on his laurels.  Sure it's a gamble, but based upon his trajectory it's a good bet to make.


   
ReplyQuote
College Hockey Addict
(@collegehockeyaddict)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 3708
Rep Pts: 9318
 

We all know @cowgirl decision to get his jersey or not will be the determining factor on how this deal turns out. 😆 


   
ReplyQuote
Cowgirl
(@cowgirl)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3278
Rep Pts: 8089
Post on old board: 10120
 

Posted by: @collegehockeyaddict

We all know @cowgirl decision to get his jersey or not will be the determining factor on how this deal turns out. 😆 

I have a Wild jersey I’d like to get Faberized…is it okay to now?  😬😆

 


   
ReplyQuote
Greyeagle
(@greyeagle)
Mayasich Level Moderator Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4306
Rep Pts: 11749
Post on old board: 21741
 

Posted by: @slap-shot

....won't be a locker-room cancer,...

Nice way of saying he wasn't a badger or phew.  😎 😉 

 

Posted by: @cowgirl

I have a Wild jersey I’d like to get Faberized…is it okay to now?  😬😆

😀


Season 5 No GIF by The Office

 

“When your best friend is the son of God, you get tired of losing every argument.”

― Christopher Moore, Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's Childhood Pal
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


   
ReplyQuote




gopheritall
(@gopheritall)
Micheletti Level Golden
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 362
Rep Pts: 712
 

Does anyone know if we can watch the Wild game locally? ESPN+ shows the game as blacked out for streaming.

I have Comcast if that matters. 


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @gopheritall

Does anyone know if we can watch the Wild game locally? ESPN+ shows the game as blacked out for streaming.

I have Comcast if that matters. 

Wild.com will have a stream available. Although the roster for the game is barely even AHL level

 


   
gopheritall reacted
ReplyQuote
gopheritall
(@gopheritall)
Micheletti Level Golden
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 362
Rep Pts: 712
 

Posted by: @j22

Posted by: @gopheritall

Does anyone know if we can watch the Wild game locally? ESPN+ shows the game as blacked out for streaming.

I have Comcast if that matters. 

Wild.com will have a stream available. Although the roster for the game is barely even AHL level

 

Luckily I can stream my desktop browser to my Chromecast. I am starved for hockey so anything is good.

 


   
ReplyQuote
fightclub30
(@fightclub30)
Bonin Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 452
Rep Pts: 1099
 

Jesper Wallstedt has been signed to a contract extension.  $4,400,000 over 2 years.  Begins next year.  He is paid $925,000 this season.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

I almost made it through 2 periods before remembering how much I hate watching Marc-andre Fleury play 


   
ReplyQuote
Koho
 Koho
(@koho)
Wooger Level
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 126
Rep Pts: 401
 

I must have missed the article where they explained the NHL rule change, where if you are standing against the boards holding the puck and an opposing player takes your legs out with his leg, you are guilty of a 'being tripped' penalty.  I hope the Wild pull this out in regulation so it doesn't matter.  I don't know how a ref could possibly see that as a penalty on Brodin.


   
ReplyQuote
Karlsson
(@karlsson)
Brooks Level
Joined: 10 years ago
Posts: 2823
Rep Pts: 5863
 

I keep reminding myself that they should suck this year and keep wheeling Fleury out there instead of rushing Wallstedt. 


   
ReplyQuote




J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @koho

I must have missed the article where they explained the NHL rule change, where if you are standing against the boards holding the puck and an opposing player takes your legs out with his leg, you are guilty of a 'being tripped' penalty.  I hope the Wild pull this out in regulation so it doesn't matter.  I don't know how a ref could possibly see that as a penalty on Brodin.

https://twitter.com/SpokedZ/status/1845273286894043529

 


   
ReplyQuote
Karlsson
(@karlsson)
Brooks Level
Joined: 10 years ago
Posts: 2823
Rep Pts: 5863
 

Evidently the ref apologized to Brodin at the start of the third period. It failed to take the goal off the scoreboard, though. 


   
ReplyQuote
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1220
Rep Pts: 1800
Post on old board: 6912
 

Posted by: @karlsson

Evidently the ref apologized to Brodin at the start of the third period. It failed to take the goal off the scoreboard, though. 

F-ck that referee apologizing, get the call right in front of your face correct. Wild blew a point last night, when was the last time KK converted in a SO, seems like about one year. Bury the damn puck. 

 


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Between Minnesota and Iowa, the Wild played 5 games in the past 4 days. Jesper Wallstedt played zero minutes. How does that make any sense?


   
ReplyQuote
bearpaw28
(@bearpaw28)
Leopold Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1220
Rep Pts: 1800
Post on old board: 6912
 

Posted by: @j22

Between Minnesota and Iowa, the Wild played 5 games in the past 4 days. Jesper Wallstedt played zero minutes. How does that make any sense?

You’re 100% correct…And this Wild team is so Fning DUMB, can’t take a penalty with 5 seconds left in 3rd period. I’m already sick of watching this clown show after 3 games. 

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

Posted by: @karlsson

Evidently the ref apologized to Brodin at the start of the third period. It failed to take the goal off the scoreboard, though. 

 

This bothers me. Stand your ground during the game. If it was a wrong call, and you apologize DURING the game, those players are going to chirp you on all your calls, and possibly affect calls you make in the game. AFTER the game, sure, apologize, explain what you saw in real time, etc. 

Basically, stand your ground until the competition is over. 

 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

Posted by: @karlsson

Evidently the ref apologized to Brodin at the start of the third period. It failed to take the goal off the scoreboard, though. 

 

This bothers me. Stand your ground during the game. If it was a wrong call, and you apologize DURING the game, those players are going to chirp you on all your calls, and possibly affect calls you make in the game. AFTER the game, sure, apologize, explain what you saw in real time, etc. 

Basically, stand your ground until the competition is over. 

 

Couldn't disagree more.

Quality referees have a constant running dialogue with everyone in the game. Aknowledging a mistake, especially when everyone already knows you made it, only helps an official.

 


   
gator reacted
ReplyQuote




The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

Have talked with many a referee up to the NCAA level, and they all have said (paraphrased) "This is what I saw when I made the call." AFTER the game, and they may have seen replays by that point, they might have changed their view. But IN-GAME, if you cave a little, they WILL have more pressure from players to force them to second-guess, or alter their calls, and that's even worse in the long run. 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

Have talked with many a referee up to the NCAA level, and they all have said (paraphrased) "This is what I saw when I made the call." AFTER the game, and they may have seen replays by that point, they might have changed their view. But IN-GAME, if you cave a little, they WILL have more pressure from players to force them to second-guess, or alter their calls, and that's even worse in the long run. 

I'm sure you've talked to tons of hockey officials, that have their games recorded and televised, about this exact situation.

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

It was a bad call. But give an inch, you give a foot. Again IN-GAME, you don't budge. You can't, due to possible future influence. 

It stinks, but that's the way it is. 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

It was a bad call. But give an inch, you give a foot. Again IN-GAME, you don't budge. You can't, due to possible future influence. 

It stinks, but that's the way it is. 

What is it that you think admitting a mistake would change about an officials job?

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

Because then players will chirp about every call after that, and then the official may or may not think about the call they made, or will make, and alter the calls/play/etc. Officials have flat out told me that. 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

Because then players will chirp about every call after that, and then the official may or may not think about the call they made, or will make, and alter the calls/play/etc. Officials have flat out told me that. 

You think the players don't chirp about every call regardless? They have multiple Ipads on the bench and a giant television right above them. I guarantee that everyone in the arena knew it was the wrong call before they even dropped the puck for the PP. You think nobody on the Wild bench made the official aware of any of this? 

You really think that an official admitting a mistake is actually going to change his thought process? If he waits until after the game, do the Wild then get a rain check to control his thoughts during the next game he calls, or is there some sort of statute of limitations for having integrity?

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

In real time? Yes, it will affect the official's thinking. They start to think "I blew that call, did I blow this one?" They may be correct, they may be incorrect. The seeds of doubt have been planted, though. 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote




J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

In real time? Yes, it will affect the official's thinking. They start to think "I blew that call, did I blow this one?" They may be correct, they may be incorrect. The seeds of doubt have been planted, though. 

This is getting entertaining

 

Just to be clear- What you're saying above, only happens if an official admits he made a mistake during a game?  As long as he refuses to acknowledge the mistake until after the game, then he will never question his decision making? And you think players will go easier on him for doing so?

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

Posted by: @j22

Posted by: @the-rube

In real time? Yes, it will affect the official's thinking. They start to think "I blew that call, did I blow this one?" They may be correct, they may be incorrect. The seeds of doubt have been planted, though. 

This is getting entertaining

 

Just to be clear- What you're saying above, only happens if an official admits he made a mistake during a game?  As long as he refuses to acknowledge the mistake until after the game, then he will never question his decision making? And you think players will go easier on him for doing so?

 

I've been told so. It's like instant replay after a game in pro or NCAA. They acknowledge the mistake (see the recent on-side kick ruling in the MN football game) and learn from it. But in-game, and I STRESS that part, they stick with the call they made. Consistency. Make a call, stick with it, and call it both ways throughout the game.  

 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

Posted by: @j22

Posted by: @the-rube

In real time? Yes, it will affect the official's thinking. They start to think "I blew that call, did I blow this one?" They may be correct, they may be incorrect. The seeds of doubt have been planted, though. 

This is getting entertaining

 

Just to be clear- What you're saying above, only happens if an official admits he made a mistake during a game?  As long as he refuses to acknowledge the mistake until after the game, then he will never question his decision making? And you think players will go easier on him for doing so?

 

I've been told so. It's like instant replay after a game in pro or NCAA. They acknowledge the mistake (see the recent on-side kick ruling in the MN football game) and learn from it. But in-game, and I STRESS that part, they stick with the call they made. Consistency. Make a call, stick with it, and call it both ways throughout the game.  

 

Now I'm not even sure that you understand the discussion. You do understand that the official in the Brodin discussion didn't change anything? He saw a replay of the penalty he called and realized that he made the wrong call. He then told Brodin that he made the wrong call.

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

I fully understand the discussion. He admitted it in-game, which was a bad decision. There is the "crack in the armor" so to speak. Once you get in a ref's head IN-GAME, the ref's calls are now POSSIBLY (stress that part) influenced by admitting a previous mistake. 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

I fully understand the discussion. He admitted it in-game, which was a bad decision. There is the "crack in the armor" so to speak. Once you get in a ref's head IN-GAME, the ref's calls are now POSSIBLY (stress that part) influenced by admitting a previous mistake. 

Ok, using your theory- If a linesman gets an offside call overturned during a game by a replay review. Does he then have to remove himself from the rest of the game because of a "crack in the armor"?

 


   
ReplyQuote
The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

No, but he will re-think his decisions from that point forward. 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @the-rube

No, but he will re-think his decisions from that point forward. 

And how long will that self doubt last? or does it depend on when he realizes he made a mistake?

 


   
ReplyQuote




The Rube
(@the-rube)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5912
Rep Pts: 8641
Post on old board: 35040
 

Posted by: @j22

Posted by: @the-rube

No, but he will re-think his decisions from that point forward. 

And how long will that self doubt last? or does it depend on when he realizes he made a mistake?

 

It will last the game, until he can review said game and adjust for future games. 

 

When you tell somebody somethin', it depends on what part of the United States you're standin' in... as to just how dumb you are.


   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 4