NCAA Rules Committe...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCAA Rules Committee proposed changes

16 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
804 Views
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2836
Rep Pts: 5612
Post on old board: 10695
Topic starter  

A mixed bag to my thinking:

https://www.ncaa.org/news/2022/6/17/media-center-ice-hockey-rules-committee-proposes-changes-to-video-review-challenges.aspx

 

Good/probably good:

NHL Offsides rule.  If your skate is over the blue line (in contact or not) you're onside.

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue) and no players on the ice after intermission, except those actually playing (this was I thought technically the rule for a long time, just never enforced... either enforce it or get rid of it)

Intermissions either 12 or 15 minutes, no option for 18.  (18 minutes is ridiculous.  12 at times seems a little short, but I'm mostly OK with it)

Covering the puck in the crease becoming reviewable by coaches challenge.  How this wasn't reviewable before, I can't understand, but it definitely explains a lot of situations where I've seen it happen in play, but no challenge/review.

 

Maybe good/maybe bad:

Challenges - Essentially, you keep a challenge if it's upheld as I read it (you still lose the timeout).  If you lose it, you can still challenge, but get a 2 minute minor if it's not upheld.  Goalie contact/offside/played with a high stick will require a coaches challenge.

Option for a 5 Minute Major with no ejection on CFB/Contact to Head - Whether this is actually good will depend on what the guidance turns out to be

Supplementary Discipline only for egregious actions - Again, depends on the guidance, I saw several times the last several years (including in games where the Gophers weren't even involved) where I honestly thought someone deserved additional suspension, but it very rarely happens.

Review on offside, if the defending team gains possession, this doesn't negate a review.  Really not sure on this one.  If you "gain possession" and try to clear, but it gets intercepted, sure, that shouldn't negate the offsides really, but, if you gain possession, have the puck for several seconds and a couple passes, at that point, that should be the end of it.

Playing the puck with a High Stick in the defensive end is treated like a hand pass, no line change.  Not sure how I feel about this one, leaning toward "meh"

 

Bad:

(This is not a change, but discussed in the article) All regular season games are mandatory 5 Minute 3x3, and allowing shootouts in regular season games per conference choice.   I hate both of these options.  Only shootouts should be in-season tournaments in 1st round or 3rd place games, and 3x3 is ridiculous.  Yes, it can be fun to watch for entertainment value, but neither should actually count for anything.  If you to to 3x3 or Shootout, it should be in the books as a tie, and you only use the Stupid Human Tricks to figure out who advances in a tournament where both teams are playing the next day anyway.

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
Quote
HandyNotDan
(@handyman)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1978
Rep Pts: 5655
Post on old board: 28736
 

Yeah the stupid lengths hockey goes to to avoid ties is ridiculous.  3x3 is entertaining in that it is just video game hockey but it should never decide anything and shootouts should only count for seeding type situations.  Ties are fine.


   
ReplyQuote
Jupiter ♃
(@jupiter)
Brooks Level Admin
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1890
Rep Pts: 5823
Post on old board: 15786
 
Steve MN wrote...

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue)

Actually this happens a lot... For those of us that get there before the crowd is let it, you will regularly see players out there in shorts and a stick. Sometimes just warming up a bit. It is also common for a few Gophers to be out in their shoes throwing a football around. So this does happen often.

Do not like how this board is run?
Get your own board!


   
ReplyQuote
Cowgirl
(@cowgirl)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3354
Rep Pts: 8335
Post on old board: 10120
 
Jupiter wrote...
Steve MN wrote…

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue)

Actually this happens a lot… For those of us that get there before the crowd is let it, you will regularly see players out there in shorts and a stick. Sometimes just warming up a bit. It is also common for a few Gophers to be out in their shoes throwing a football around. So this does happen often.

And what is the problem with this?


   
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5970
Rep Pts: 14201
Post on old board: 9626
 
Cowgirl wrote...
Jupiter wrote…
Steve MN wrote…

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue)

Actually this happens a lot… For those of us that get there before the crowd is let it, you will regularly see players out there in shorts and a stick. Sometimes just warming up a bit. It is also common for a few Gophers to be out in their shoes throwing a football around. So this does happen often.

And what is the problem with this?

Wild guess is they are afraid both teams may be out on the ice without any officials and both teams could go Fighting Whioux on each other. Another slightly less likely guess is that some teams may use that time as "extra" practice, but I'm not sure how in season practices work or if there is a limit.

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
ReplyQuote
g-manpuck
(@g-manpuck)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1120
Rep Pts: 2762
Post on old board: 6782
 
Jupiter wrote...
Steve MN wrote…

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue)

Actually this happens a lot… For those of us that get there before the crowd is let it, you will regularly see players out there in shorts and a stick. Sometimes just warming up a bit. It is also common for a few Gophers to be out in their shoes throwing a football around. So this does happen often.

Here in Mankato it happens every game that a few players from both teams come out with only shorts and a stick, it's just a part of their pregame routine.  Daniel Brickley a few years ago had a pretty specific routine that he stuck to every game.

I am the official Iowa Hawkeye football fan of GPL!


   
ReplyQuote
Iceburg
(@iceburg)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 1645
Rep Pts: 3054
Post on old board: 7833
 

In the old days the Gophers and Michigan got into a big skirmish during pregame warmups. I think it started when Don Micheletti went down to the Michigan end to retrieve some pucks. Not sure of all the particulars as it all happened before I arrived. This was at the old Mariucci. I believe this started mandatory officials on ice for warmups.


   
ReplyQuote




Greyeagle
(@greyeagle)
Mayasich Level Moderator Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4399
Rep Pts: 12062
Post on old board: 21741
 
Iceburg wrote...

In the old days the Gophers and Michigan got into a big skirmish during pregame warmups. I think it started when Don Micheletti went down to the Michigan end to retrieve some pucks. Not sure of all the particulars as it all happened before I arrived. This was at the old Mariucci. I believe this started mandatory officials on ice for warmups.

Pat Micheletti tells a great story about this incident.

Apparently his dad hated coming to the Twin Cities but would trek down for games then immediately head back to Hibbing after the game.  So his brother Don gets in a brawl before the game and gets a game misconduct (at least) for his role.  Pat and his parents show up just before game time and hear the announcement of the penalties and Don won't be playing.  Pat's dad stands up and says "Let's go" and they drive back to Hibbing.

“When your best friend is the son of God, you get tired of losing every argument.”

― Christopher Moore, Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's Childhood Pal
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


   
ReplyQuote
Northern Gopher 218
(@northerngopher218)
Wooger Level
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 272
Rep Pts: 377
 
frozen4champs wrote...
Cowgirl wrote…
Jupiter wrote…
Steve MN wrote…

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue)

Actually this happens a lot… For those of us that get there before the crowd is let it, you will regularly see players out there in shorts and a stick. Sometimes just warming up a bit. It is also common for a few Gophers to be out in their shoes throwing a football around. So this does happen often.

And what is the problem with this?

Wild guess is they are afraid both teams may be out on the ice without any officials and both teams could go Fighting Whioux on each other. Another slightly less likely guess is that some teams may use that time as “extra” practice, but I’m not sure how in season practices work or if there is a limit.

Shocker, Schlossman says it's because of a Whioux player.

https://www.therinklive.com/mens-division-1/new-ncaa-hockey-rules-proposals-aim-at-cutting-down-number-of-video-reviews


   
ReplyQuote
gator
(@gator)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4012
Rep Pts: 6305
Post on old board: 16243
 
Cowgirl wrote...
And what is the problem with this?

Wouldn’t be surprised it be because they’re not wearing a helmet. Though like Jup said, you get to the rink early enough you see this at all levels of hockey.

Keep your stick on the ice...


   
ReplyQuote
thinkbui
(@thinkbui)
Bonin Level
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 740
Rep Pts: 1075
Post on old board: 11106
 

Are we talking about just the physical ice or also the immediate vicinity (ex. the benches)? I've seen players loitering around the rink at Mariucci all the time, but I don't recall seeing them actually on it before warmups. I don't see anything wrong with that, especially since they stay separated, so are they just trying to prevent players from pulling a Michaud or are they tackling another problem I don't see?

Trigeminal Neuralgia Awareness
Not every disease is visible. Not every pain comes from an obvious wound. Some people you see day-to-day may be suffering in ways you or I may never understand and fighting just to live a normal life. Please consider contributing to the Facial Pain Association and together we can find a cure.


   
ReplyQuote
gator
(@gator)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4012
Rep Pts: 6305
Post on old board: 16243
 

Some players like to come out on the ice early before warmups. Mostly in a t-shirt, shorts, socks or no socks and flip flops. They might do some stick handling drills or even tape their stick. It happens at all levels.

Keep your stick on the ice...


   
ReplyQuote
HandyNotDan
(@handyman)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1978
Rep Pts: 5655
Post on old board: 28736
 
Jupiter wrote...
Steve MN wrote…

No player on the ice before the pregame process (likely not a real issue)

Actually this happens a lot… For those of us that get there before the crowd is let it, you will regularly see players out there in shorts and a stick. Sometimes just warming up a bit. It is also common for a few Gophers to be out in their shoes throwing a football around. So this does happen often.

Mark Hartigan for SCCC used to do this all the time.  He would flip pucks around and suck and I think he wore sandals on the ice.


   
ReplyQuote
Slap Shot
(@slap-shot)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 4126
Rep Pts: 8513
Post on old board: 18942
 

Harty was robbed!


   
ReplyQuote




Eric Vegoe
(@eric-vegoe)
Bonin Level
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 307
Rep Pts: 1474
 

I'm venturing into old man yelling territory... but I don't see any legit reason for players to do the stuff they've done on the ice before games. Like none of the examples I've heard sound actually helpful. Find a different space in the arena to get ready for the game. Ice is slippery and there's more bad that can happen than good. If I was a coach, then I'd probably yell at the players about it.

Probably silly that there's a rule... but that's where we are today. Okay... I'll step off the soap box.


   
ReplyQuote
Cowgirl
(@cowgirl)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3354
Rep Pts: 8335
Post on old board: 10120
 

And to play devils advocate - I see no reason kids can’t go on their own ice and dink around before games.

But to your point it’s most likely a CYA move as inevitably something would eventually happen - and nobody can skin a knee without a lawsuit these days.


   
ReplyQuote