Opponent Recruiting
 
Notifications
Clear all




Opponent Recruiting

521 Posts
70 Users
41 Reactions
27.4 K Views
Iceburg
(@iceburg)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 1545
Rep Pts: 2899
Post on old board: 7833

   
ReplyQuote
BlueBandit24
(@bluebandit24)
Bonin Level Golden
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 553
Rep Pts: 1258
 

Like most, assumed he was a UMD lock. Great get for the Irish.


   
ReplyQuote
Bertogliat
(@bertogliat)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 2425
Rep Pts: 4509
Post on old board: 12555
 

I just don't get the draw of Notre Dame for hockey.  It's a good school but so are many others.  It's also in Indiana.  

 

I just do not understand.


   
ReplyQuote
Eric Vegoe
(@eric-vegoe)
Bonin Level
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 290
Rep Pts: 1392
 

Posted by: @bertogliat

I just don't get the draw of Notre Dame for hockey.  It's a good school but so are many others.  It's also in Indiana.  

I just do not understand.

The religious draw of Notre Dame is pretty significant for some players.

 


   
ReplyQuote
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2639
Rep Pts: 5065
Post on old board: 10695
 

And, let's be honest, from a standpoint of connections/name recognition/etc, other than Harvard and Yale, what school out there really competes?  Plus, you're less than two hours from Chicago, closer than even WisconSIN is.

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
ReplyQuote
Bertogliat
(@bertogliat)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 2425
Rep Pts: 4509
Post on old board: 12555
 

Posted by: @steve-mn

And, let's be honest, from a standpoint of connections/name recognition/etc, other than Harvard and Yale, what school out there really competes?  Plus, you're less than two hours from Chicago, closer than even WisconSIN is.

 

If you're expecting these guys to land a job on Wall Street and flaunt the Notre Dame name, then I could see a small advantage.  But I hire people from time to time and if I saw Notre Dame on the resume vs Michigan or Minnesota, it would not help them AT ALL.  But I work in pharma which isn't as stuck up with college names as Wall Street.

 

Personally I don't see most of these player looking for upper echelon careers. 

 

I can see Vegoe's point of it helping to be a Catholic School.

 


   
ReplyQuote
maroon and gold
(@maroon_and_gold)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 3043
Rep Pts: 7918
 

It’s just a big brand. It’s always been a bit of a draw whether the program was successful or not. Now that they’re getting a coach who might try to score goals it’s paying off in recruiting. 


   
ReplyQuote




maroon and gold
(@maroon_and_gold)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 3043
Rep Pts: 7918
 

Kade Stengrim to St. Cloud


   
ReplyQuote
maroon and gold
(@maroon_and_gold)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 3043
Rep Pts: 7918
 

Logan Lutner to Denver. Ouch.


   
ReplyQuote
BlueBandit24
(@bluebandit24)
Bonin Level Golden
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 553
Rep Pts: 1258

   
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5694
Rep Pts: 13282
Post on old board: 9626
 

I bet this isn't the only time he changes schools... People were questioning why Bob passed....

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
ReplyQuote
maroon and gold
(@maroon_and_gold)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 3043
Rep Pts: 7918
 

Posted by: @frozen4champs

I bet this isn't the only time he changes schools... People were questioning why Bob passed....

Idk… i still hope his next stop is Minnesota 😉

 


   
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5694
Rep Pts: 13282
Post on old board: 9626
 

https://twitter.com/wyshynski/status/1834564906693116220

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
ReplyQuote
Slap Shot
(@slap-shot)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 3883
Rep Pts: 7905
Post on old board: 18942
 

Stephen Colbert Popcorn GIF

   
ReplyQuote




maroon and gold
(@maroon_and_gold)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 3043
Rep Pts: 7918
 

This is a huge domino to fall. As I understand it, CHL players are basically fair game at this point.


   
ReplyQuote
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2639
Rep Pts: 5065
Post on old board: 10695
 

Posted by: @maroon_and_gold

This is a huge domino to fall. As I understand it, CHL players are basically fair game at this point.

There's a proposed Class Action for a lawsuit that was filed, but hasn't even been heard yet, much less decided.

Unless something changed in the background that I haven't heard about, CHL players aren't allowed.  I'm presuming this "commitment" is solely intended to give the suit in question an actual example of someone that the NCAA has refused to allow let play.

Paging @skiumahlaw to the "Opponent Recruiting" thread

 

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
ReplyQuote
Slap Shot
(@slap-shot)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 3883
Rep Pts: 7905
Post on old board: 18942
 

Posted by: @steve-mn

Posted by: @maroon_and_gold

This is a huge domino to fall. As I understand it, CHL players are basically fair game at this point.

There's a proposed Class Action for a lawsuit that was filed, but hasn't even been heard yet, much less decided.

Unless something changed in the background that I haven't heard about, CHL players aren't allowed.  I'm presuming this "commitment" is solely intended to give the suit in question an actual example of someone that the NCAA has refused to allow let play.

Paging @skiumahlaw to the "Opponent Recruiting" thread

 

This is why I used theeating popcorn gif. Much remains to be seen.

 


   
Steve MN reacted
ReplyQuote
SkiUMahLaw
(@skiumahlaw)
Micheletti Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 245
Rep Pts: 737
 

Posted by: @steve-mn

Posted by: @maroon_and_gold

This is a huge domino to fall. As I understand it, CHL players are basically fair game at this point.

There's a proposed Class Action for a lawsuit that was filed, but hasn't even been heard yet, much less decided.

Unless something changed in the background that I haven't heard about, CHL players aren't allowed.  I'm presuming this "commitment" is solely intended to give the suit in question an actual example of someone that the NCAA has refused to allow let play.

Paging @skiumahlaw to the "Opponent Recruiting" thread

 

 

Sorry-- late to the game.  Busy weekend!

There is a class action currently filed against the NCAA by CHL players on antitrust grounds saying that it is unfair restraint of trade by not allowing CHL players to play college hockey.  Essentially that the NCAA allows Swedish/Finnish/Czech players to participate but not CHL players to do so, and that is unfair.  The NCAA identified this as a potential issue last year but declined to address it-- in my estimation because I still don't think the CHL case is that strong.

If you review the 10th Circuit's O'Bannon decision, which opened up the floodgates with NIL and the NCAA, I don't buy the CHL argument.  The Court there indicated the NCAA could still set eligibility rules related to their sport itself-- but just not do so with items that are unrelated to the sport.  So a player who gets money for running a camp outside of their work as a student-athlete should be allowed, but the NCAA would still be free to dictate a player only gets 4 years of eligibility.  That allowed for NIL activities by players-- but still restricted pay-for-play.  And the basis of the O'Bannon decision was antitrust.

Essentially that means the NCAA has jurisdiction to determine rules of the games it plays-- provided the rules are connected with the sport themselves.  Certainly, restriction of competition with professionals fits that bill.  Just because they allow it from Finland or Sweden doesn't mean the NCAA has to allow it from Canada too. 

So I don't think the case is that compelling.  Certainly the NCAA is on a Court losing streak, but that doesn't automatically mean this is a winner either.

In any event, that the House lawsuit settlement is in jeopardy may make it all moot anyway.  If that case doesn't settle I am unsure if the NCAA even survives to oversee hockey.  NCAA schools will not proceed allowing booster clubs to effectively control their athletic departments.

 


   
Greyeagle reacted
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5694
Rep Pts: 13282
Post on old board: 9626
 

Not a huge surprise as his brother went that route, but he is a great prospect.  Played at Shattuck's and Chan/Chaska bantam AA.

Edit-- Original tweet was deleted, so here is another one. He was committed to Denver. 

https://twitter.com/EdmOilKings/status/1836851636138037720

 

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
ReplyQuote
Young gopher diehard 2
(@younggopherdiehard2)
Wooger Level
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 161
Rep Pts: 356
 

Posted by: @frozen4champs

Not a huge surprise as his brother went that route, but he is a great prospect.  Played at Shattuck's and Chan/Chaska bantam AA. 

https://twitter.com/sydneyisawolf/status/1836854842469286261

 

I would expect he is betting that CHL prospects remain eligible. I would think Denver will go after his brother as well. 

 


   
ReplyQuote
frozen4champs
(@frozen4champs)
Mayasich Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 5694
Rep Pts: 13282
Post on old board: 9626
 

Posted by: @younggopherdiehard2

Posted by: @frozen4champs

Not a huge surprise as his brother went that route, but he is a great prospect.  Played at Shattuck's and Chan/Chaska bantam AA. 

https://twitter.com/sydneyisawolf/status/1836854842469286261

 

I would expect he is betting that CHL prospects remain eligible. I would think Denver will go after his brother as well. 

 

These days you never know, but his brother will be 20 this year and was drafted by the Panthers so I expect his brother to go pro and not even consider college. I don't know the family, but it appears they are very "hands on" with their son's hockey careers and reminds me of another hockey family that the Gophers staff dealt with. 

 

I'm 50% factual and 50% sarcastic. When you get to know me, you will know which is which.


   
ReplyQuote




Page 11 / 11