Hockey Officiating
 
Notifications
Clear all




Hockey Officiating

165 Posts
39 Users
57 Reactions
6,576 Views
Jupiter ♃
(@jupiter)
Brooks Level Admin
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1880
Rep Pts: 5786
Post on old board: 15786
 

What the hell is happening?

https://twitter.com/GopherPuckLive/status/1763977834693878105?s=20

Do not like how this board is run?
Get your own board!


   
ReplyQuote
College Hockey Addict
(@collegehockeyaddict)
Mariucci Level
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 3713
Rep Pts: 9328
 

On the front angle it appears that the Ohio State player raises his elbow and catches the guy with his stick and elbow. I am guessing that is why it was called.


   
ReplyQuote
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2744
Rep Pts: 5375
Post on old board: 10695
 

As bad as I've thought some of the reviews on Gopher/opponent goals have been recently (not last night, that one I was OK with), this call is absolutely absurd and so much worse.  I get looking out for player safety, but, if you're skating and someone runs into you form behind with their face, that's not a penalty on you.

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
ReplyQuote
Greyeagle
(@greyeagle)
Mayasich Level Moderator Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4308
Rep Pts: 11751
Post on old board: 21741
 

Posted by: @jupiter

What the hell is happening?

https://twitter.com/GopherPuckLive/status/1763977834693878105?s=20

I figured when Bob challenged the goal in the 2nd MN would somehow end up with a Major penalty.  

 

“When your best friend is the son of God, you get tired of losing every argument.”

― Christopher Moore, Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's Childhood Pal
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


   
ReplyQuote
Steve MN
(@steve-mn)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 2744
Rep Pts: 5375
Post on old board: 10695
 

Posted by: @greyeagle

Posted by: @jupiter

What the hell is happening?

https://twitter.com/GopherPuckLive/status/1763977834693878105?s=20

I figured when Bob challenged the goal in the 2nd MN would somehow end up with a Major penalty.  

I've got to be honest, given how many of these reviews change the direction and possibly even the outcome of a game, it feels like it's either to the point of corruption, or need to replace the entire officiating staff due to complete inability to learn the rules.

 

B1G refs... corrupt, or just incompetent?


   
ReplyQuote
gator
(@gator)
Brooks Level Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 3918
Rep Pts: 6171
Post on old board: 16243
 

Posted by: @collegehockeyaddict

On the front angle it appears that the Ohio State player raises his elbow and catches the guy with his stick and elbow. I am guessing that is why it was called.

There’s nothing there to call. 

 

Keep your stick on the ice...


   
ReplyQuote
Jupiter ♃
(@jupiter)
Brooks Level Admin
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1880
Rep Pts: 5786
Post on old board: 15786
 

Posted by: @collegehockeyaddict

On the front angle it appears that the Ohio State player raises his elbow and catches the guy with his stick and elbow. I am guessing that is why it was called.

I personally think that it is a natural reaction to raise your elbow in reacting to getting hit and not knowing it is coming. The PSU player ran in to him. Plain and simple.

 

Do not like how this board is run?
Get your own board!


   
gator and Steve MN reacted
ReplyQuote




J22
 J22
(@j22)
Broten Level Golden
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 996
Rep Pts: 2321
Post on old board: 5631
 

Posted by: @steve-mn

Posted by: @greyeagle

Posted by: @jupiter

What the hell is happening?

https://twitter.com/GopherPuckLive/status/1763977834693878105?s=20

I figured when Bob challenged the goal in the 2nd MN would somehow end up with a Major penalty.  

I've got to be honest, given how many of these reviews change the direction and possibly even the outcome of a game, it feels like it's either to the point of corruption, or need to replace the entire officiating staff due to complete inability to learn the rules.

 

I know that I have said this before, but it has been a while since I watched an NCAA game where the officials could even keep up with the game. They are so overmatched that it's getting hard to watch. 

Making that PSU/OSU call during live action should get an official reprimanded. Not overturning that call after video review should get an official fired

 


   
ReplyQuote
Cowgirl
(@cowgirl)
Mariucci Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3285
Rep Pts: 8106
Post on old board: 10120
 

Was it the official at our game in wisco by chance? 


   
ReplyQuote
HockeyBum
(@hockeybum)
Micheletti Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 256
Rep Pts: 603
 

I'm working my last game of the 2023-24 season on Saturday.  Here are my stats and observations from year 2 of officiating:

77 games worked

17 Levels worked (10UB2, 10UB, 10UA, SQC, SQB2, SQB, SQA, 12UB2, 12UB, 12UA, PWC, PWB2, PWB, 15UB, 15A, BNC, BNB2)

4 dickhead coaches.  The worst one was in a GIRLS 10UB GAME (I wish I was kidding).  Fortunately, it feels like coaches were a lot better this year than last year.  Or maybe I just improved as an official?

Favorite levels to officiate:  Girls 12UA, 15UA, 15UB.  Players are polite.  Very few (if any) chippiness or BS after the whistle.  

Least favorite levels to officiate:  SQC, SQB2.  Terrible skaters who constantly fall and take others down with them.  Coaches think everything is a penalty.  Squirt games are some of the hardest for me to officiate, and they also pay the worst.  I do enjoy working SQA games though.  

Just a self-aware personal observation, but I tend to have a higher tolerance for physical play than most referees.  I don't make a lot of ticky-tack calls.  My philosophy is call the obvious stuff that everyone sees, call the stuff that impacts scoring chances, and call the dangerous stuff.  Otherwise, I tend to let 'em play.  I think most coaches appreciate that.  I worked 4 games this year with one particular ref who calls EVERYTHING, and all 4 games turned into a clown show.  I think those games averaged 10+ penalties per game, with me calling 1-2 and this partner calling 8+.  Coaches were furious at my partner in every one of those games.  "The Code" says you have your partner's back out there on the ice, but privately I agreed with the coaches.  He made the games miserable to work.  Nobody was happy, and the games took forever to finish.  I'd rather let too much go than be that ref who calls everything.  

And yeah... If you read my post from about a month ago, I'm in a much better place now.  I started a new 9-5 job in mid-February, so I'm actually getting paid to ref again.  

 


   
trixR4kids, Cowgirl, g-manpuck and 2 people reacted
ReplyQuote
HockeyBum
(@hockeybum)
Micheletti Level Golden
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 256
Rep Pts: 603
 

Any hockey officials still posting here? 

I got a comment after the game from an assistant coach a few days ago. It was a rough PWB game. Especially the 3rd period. There were 14 penalties in the game... 10 of them in the 3rd period (Lots of coincidental roughing nonsense after the whistle). It was my 2nd game of the night and I was tired.  Believe me, I just wanted to end the game as quickly as possible and go home. These idiot kids forced us to call what we did. After the game, I extend my hand. Coach looks me and doesn't shake it. Then he says "Nobody came here to watch you guys".
 
I'm 10 games into my 3rd year officiating. This is the first time I've ever been accused of being the Ref Show. If anything, I tend to let more go than the average ref.  I didn't say anything and just let it go.  I've got pretty thick skin and can handle some chirping, but for some reason this comment really bothered me.  Do you guys just ignore this?  Tack on an unsportsmanlike penalty post-game?  I've never given a Rule 601 penalty and am very hesitant to do so.  I get that emotions are high immediately after the game.  I see the same teams/coaches multiple times a season and don't want to get a reputation as the sensitive ref who can't take a little heat.  Where do you draw the line?

   
ReplyQuote
GopherPete
(@gopherpete)
Wooger Level
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 192
Rep Pts: 477
 

Not a ref, but as much as what the coach said may have hurt the ego, I don't see how you could penalize that comment. Not a penalty in my mind. Just let it go and move on.


   
ReplyQuote
Greyeagle
(@greyeagle)
Mayasich Level Moderator Golden
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4308
Rep Pts: 11751
Post on old board: 21741
 

The coach is a self centered ass.  

If it were me it chalk not doing anything additional as my own personal warning.  If he acts that way in the future let him know he's been on double secret probation.  

 

“When your best friend is the son of God, you get tired of losing every argument.”

― Christopher Moore, Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's Childhood Pal
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


   
ReplyQuote
upnorthkid
(@upnorthkid)
Broten Level
Joined: 10 years ago
Posts: 1281
Rep Pts: 2881
 

Guy could probably use looking in the mirror if his team is committing all these penalties and coincidental shit. Lot of coaches it’s pretty typical shit that they let this kind of thing go then act all woe is me when it’s called like it’s not partly their fault they aren’t controlling their players


   
ReplyQuote




trixR4kids
(@trixr4kids)
Broten Level
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1172
Rep Pts: 2369
Post on old board: 15139
 

Yeah it’d be one thing if the coincidental penalties only got called one way (or it truly wasn’t coincidental, like that penalty Matthew Wood got in Madison 😂) but sounds like the coach is just oblivious. It happens. 


   
ReplyQuote
Page 4 / 4