Portal Forum General General Discussion Let’s get to know each other… Reply To: Let’s get to know each other…

#168011
Steve MNSteve MN
  • Posts: 1059
  • GoldenHas donated $ to the upkeep of GPL
Up
0
Down
::

The Rube wrote:


Steve MN wrote:


The Rube wrote:


His and Metallica’s version are really good. His is more tired/worn out, while Metallica’s version channels the rage.

Great way to describe the difference between the versions. Which one is better really depends on my mood.

Mo def on the mood. If I’m at home, it’s most likely Seger’s version. On the road? It’s Metallica’s. It really is amazing hearing difference in covers, on what the artist wants to portray, in combination with the original, etc etc etc. Tone makes such a difference. Sometimes it’s night and day.

Most likely for me “on the road” means on the bike, so, definitely Metallica for that. And yes, some covers can be really good. Others, of course, not so much.